Total Chaos Review: A Dirty, Janky, Masterpiece of Misery That I Can't Stop Playing
This game looks like it was dredged out of a sewer in 2005, and I mean that as the highest possible compliment.
Most modern horror games are too clean. They have high-resolution textures, perfectly motion-captured faces, and jumpscares that were clearly focus-tested in a boardroom. They are theme park rides. They are safe.
Total Chaos is not safe.
Originally conceived as a total conversion mod for Doom II, yes, the game from 1994, this standalone release is a testament to the fact that art direction beats graphical fidelity every single time. It is gritty, it is noisy, and it feels actively hostile to your existence.
I spent about 20 hours trapped in Fort Oasis, and by the end of it, my nerves were shot, my inventory was full of garbage, and I was absolutely in love.
Welcome to Fort Oasis, Enjoy Your Tetanus
The premise is standard survival horror fare, almost to a fault. You are a coast guard responder. There is a distress signal. You crash on a spooky island called Fort Oasis.
But the second you step into the concrete bowels of this mining colony, the cliché melts away into pure atmosphere. The developers at Trigger Happy Interactive have created a world that feels physically oppressive.
The aesthetic is a grainy, grey-washed nightmare. It looks like Silent Hill and STALKER had a baby, and then abandoned that baby in a coal mine.
It’s not just dark, it’s also dirty. The walls look like they would give you a disease if you touched them. The lighting is harsh and industrial. It’s a masterclass in environmental storytelling where the environment is screaming "leave" at the top of its lungs.
The Audio Will Mess You Up
If you play this game with speakers instead of headphones, you are playing it wrong. The sound design is, without a doubt, the star of the show.
It isn't just the monsters screeching at you. It’s the silence. It’s the dripping water. It’s the distant, metallic groans of a facility that shouldn't be alive but somehow is.
The standout feature for me was the save system. You save your game at these little, spinning record players. At first, the music they play is a comfort, a tiny island of safety in the dark.
But as you go deeper, and as your character's sanity starts to fracture, the music on those records starts to warp. It bends. It slows down. It becomes discordant. It is such a subtle, brilliant way to tell you that things are getting worse without saying a word.
Survival Is a Balancing Act (and a Pain in the Ass)
Total Chaos isn't just a walking simulator with scares. It’s a dense survival game with systems that hate you.
You have to manage hunger, bleeding, stamina, and health. The brilliance here is how these systems fight each other.
Let’s say you get hit. You are bleeding. You find a stimpak needle to heal yourself. Great, right? No. Stabbing yourself with that needle stops the bleeding, sure, but now you’ve caused a "blood loss" penalty from the injection itself, and the drugs make you hungrier.
So now you have to eat. But all you have is a can of Rotten Meat. You eat it to fix the hunger, but now your health drops because you just ate literal garbage.
It is a constant, desperate tug-of-war. You are never fully "okay." You are just mitigating the disaster of your own body.
The Hoarder's Curse
Then there is the inventory. Oh god, the inventory. It uses a weight system, and if you are anything like me, you will spend the entire game over-encumbered.
The game is littered with junk. Empty cans, scrap metal, axe heads without handles. My gamer brain screams, "I might need this later!" So I pick it all up.
The result? My stamina regeneration tanked. I was sluggish. I couldn't run away from monsters effectively. I was literally being weighed down by my own greed and paranoia. It is a brilliant mechanical punishment for the survivalist mindset.
Combat: Heavy, Clunky, and Visceral
You will find guns in Total Chaos, but treat them like holy relics. Ammo is scarce, and you will mostly be relying on melee.
You’ll craft shivs, pickaxes, and sledgehammers out of the scrap you find. The combat feels heavy. When you swing a sledgehammer, it takes a second to connect, but when it hits, it hits.
There is a sickening "wet" thud when you connect with a monster. It feels desperate. You aren't a super soldier; you're a guy frantically swinging a piece of metal at a nightmare.
The enemies are fantastic freaks. The "Splitters" are a highlight, big, beefy monstrosities with a vertical mouth that splits their entire body.
I learned the hard way that you can actually throw a brick or a hammer into that mouth to stun them. It’s those little interactions that elevate the combat above just "click to kill."
The Janky Elephant in the Room
I have to be real with you. This game has jank. It has "Eurojank" written all over it, even if the devs aren't all European.
I saw textures pop in late. I had enemies get stuck on doorframes, running in place while I beat them to death with a shovel. I had moments where the AI just seemed to forget I existed.
The "fodder" enemies, like the basic zombies and the little spider-goo things, can get annoying. They aren't scary after the tenth time; they’re just speed bumps that waste your weapon durability.
But honestly? I didn't care. The jank almost adds to the charm. It feels like a cursed artifact you found on a floppy disk in 1998. A polished version of this game might actually be less scary.
The "Am I Crazy?" Trope
The story does lean a little too hard into the "is it all in my head?" trope. You get the hallucinations, the cryptic radio messages from a "friend" who might not be real, the guilt-ridden backstory.
It’s familiar territory. If you’ve played Silent Hill 2 or any psychological horror game in the last decade, you know the beats.
However, the execution saves it. The voice acting is surprisingly solid, and the "visions" you have where the world shifts in real-time are visually stunning. One moment you are in a hallway, the next the walls are breathing and the floor is gone. It works.
The Verdict
Total Chaos is a triumph of atmosphere over technology. It proves that you don't need Unreal Engine 5's Nanite geometry to make someone afraid of the dark.
It is a grueling, exhausting, stressful experience. You will manage your inventory until your eyes bleed. You will eat rotten food and thank the game for it. You will listen to a warping record player and feel a chill go down your spine.
It is clunky, it is ugly, and it is one of the best horror experiences I have had all year.
8.5/10 A terrifying, rusted-out nightmare that proves high-fidelity graphics are overrated. Play it in the dark, if you dare.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
Menace from the Deep Review: When RNG Hits Harder Than Cthulhu's Morning Breath
Cubic Odyssey Review: A 1.0 Release That Feels More Like a 0.5 Alpha
Service with a Shotgun Review: VA-11 Hall-A Meets Doom, and It's a Blast
Dark Quest 4 Review: The Digital HeroQuest I've Been Waiting For
House Builder 2 Review: A Buggy, Soulless Clicker Wearing a Simulator's Skin